What is the Best Sugar Substitute For Diabetics?

Are you curious as to What is the Best Sugar Substitute For Diabetics is? While there are many sugar substitutes out there today, they are not all good. Why are artificial sweeteners bad for diabetes? It’s important to know which ones are good for you and which ones are not. Some, but maybe not all artificial sweeteners label themselves as either “diabetic-friendly” or “sugar-free” and thorough research resulted in these “sugars” as having the opposite effect in reality.

Sugar Substitutes and Diabetes

Sugar Substitutes
Sugar Substitutes

There is a different reaction from your body with sugar than there is with sugar substitutes. These sugars can inhibit with the tastes that your body is already used to. So what does this do to you?

Well this can mess up your brain and changes its thoughts which processes thoughts for you to eat more foods that are sweet and sugary.

You don’t want to be eating more sugary foods. You want to be eating less. None, in fact. Type 2 diabetes is all about controlling your blood sugar levels so you want to be staying away from the substitutes that are bad and cause these sugar cravings. I have never added sugar or salt for that matter to any food I’ve ever eaten. But then again, I’m not a coffee or a tea drinker which is where you would probably be adding sugar anyway.

There were studies done on products such as saccharin that are responsible for altering the bacterial composition in your stomach. This isn’t good because this in turn causes glucose intolerance and that is the beginning towards diabetes and metabolic syndrome in adults.

While not all adults will develop glucose intolerance, it is still possible that sugar substitutes can still aid in controlling type 2 diabetes and also with losing weight, but this may only be a possible solution if you follow it as a controlled intake and a long term management. It’s crucial that anything you are thinking of doing with regards to sugar substitutes should be discussed with your doctor. Remember that they are the professionals.

Artificial sweeteners themselves may lead to weight gain and that’s a prerequisite for type 2 diabetes. Just because they may be approved by the FDA, doesn’t necessarily mean they are healthy for you. Let’s see more of what these are and aren’t.

Sugar Substitutes:

  • Decrease your intake of energy
  • May lead you to overeat when you mix them with regular sugar
  • Will not decrease your weight if used solo
  • Can set off constant eating for the intake of energy to also be constant
  • May still increase your BMI (body mass index)
  • Are definitely less effective than exercising and decreasing your daily calories

If you are a diabetic and looking to watch and control your intake of sugar and managing weight, then these artificial sweeteners for the most part may not be suitable substitutes. But some may be and we’ll see which ones they are. Make sure you choose wisely!

Sugar Alcohols

Berries and plants contain natural sugar alcohols. The food industry manufactures kinds that are synthetic. These specific foods are noted on their labels as either “no sugar added” or “sugar free.” You have to be careful because this can be deceptive to say the least as they are still carbohydrates. It is possible to see your blood sugar increase but not as high as regular sugar would raise it.

Some Sugar Alcohols Are:

  • erythritol
  • isomalt
  • lactitol
  • sorbitol
  • xylitol

These are all approved by the FDA but they have advantages and disadvantages when it comes to your blood sugar. The advantages of sugar alcohols are that they may be responsible for helping your blood sugars and also controlling your weight. Sugar alcohols that produce sweeteners that are low calorie can give you a sweet taste with no extra calories. The one that is used in sugar free gum xylitol, helps to prevent cavities, according to research.

The disadvantages are that they can cause discomfort and abdominal gas in some folks because they only get partially digested. It’s wise to keep an eye on y our body and its reactions when consuming sugar alcohols. If you find you begin having problems, then you should cut them out and avoid them.

The Worst Sugar Substitutes


* Splenda- This substitute is also known as sucralose and has effects that are harmful to the body that include changing insulin responses, decreasing bacteria that are good in your stomach, let compounds that are toxic to be released in the baking process, and your blood glucose levels. Studies showed that obesity, type 2 diabetes, and heart disease were linked to the consumption of sucralose.

* Agave nectar- This sweetener is extremely high in fructose and that’s not good because that puts you at a higher risk for obesity, heart disease, and type 2 diabetes. Agave can have an enormous impact on your insulin levels, which will make your hormones go haywire and resulting in your chances of metabolic disease increasing. This is also due to the fact that agave actually contains a higher level of fructose than high fructose corn syrup. Yuck! Not a good choice AT ALL!

* Equal- Aspartame is a substance that Equal is made from. It can be responsible for things that are not good such as an increased risk for heart attack, headaches, and stroke. While aspartame is found in many thousands of foods, it’s diet soda that red flags over 70% of the food reactions that are being reported to the Food and Drug Administration.

* Sweet N’ Low- This has the contents of saccharin which is more than 200x sweeter than sugar is. I remember saccharin from the 1970’s and they did tests with rats that consumed saccharin and the results were a higher risk for bladder cancer. Even though there has been no definitive result in humans, saccharin  is still believed to be unsafe for humans and is a sweetener that should be avoided according to the Center for Science in the Public Interest. It is a sweetener that I would stay away from for sure.

The Best Sugar Substitutes


* Stevia- This happens to be an ingredient in Truvia which is a well known sweetener. It has no chemical additives and comes from a plant in Brazil and Peru. Stevia has no effect on your blood sugar and helps to improve insulin sensitivity, resulting in helping your body for using glucose for energy effectively. This is about the best sugar substitute you can have.

* Coconut sugar- This substitute has a variety of vitamins, antioxidants, and minerals and regular sugars do not have these. Coconut oil has a taste that resembles the taste of brown sugar. This sweetener helps to keep your insulin and blood sugar levels steadier because it has a much lower glycemic index than that of refined sugar.

* Raw honey- This is an excellent sugar substitute because it is a natural product that contains antibacterial properties. The darker the variety of honey the more of these properties exist. People who stick with honey over sugar wind up with  a better reduction in their body fat and body weight. Honey is also easier when it comes to digestion.

* Pure organic maple syrup-  This is another awesome substitute and 100% maple syrup contains over 50 antioxidant compounds that can aid with improving your skin, help to combat cancer, and fight off bloating in your stomach. But you want pure organic maple syrup that is 100% and not with corn syrup as an ingredient.

Healthy Sugar Substitutes to Add to Anything

  • Lemons
  • Raisins
  • Cinnamon
  • Grapefruit
  • Limes
  • Cranberries
  • Molasses
  • Dates

Facts About Sugar

So, in the video above it explains what the differences are between table sugar, natural sugar, and sugar substitutes. Can you try and comprehend that an average American person consumes 20 teaspoons of sugar a day? GEEZ! I remember hearing many years ago that a 16 ounce can of coca-cola contains 10 teaspoons of sugar! That’s the last time I ever had regular soda with all that sugar in it!

Sugar is everywhere and present in so many foods that you wouldn’t think contain sugar but they do. It becomes an addiction and can lead to type 2 diabetes. By now we know that this leads to weight gain and this raises the risk of tooth decay, acne, heart disease, kidney problems, and a zillion other health issues you don’t want or don’t need.

Natural Sugars

Fruit With Natural Sugars
Fruit With Natural Sugars

Listen, we all still need sugar but where we get it from and what kind, is vital to avoiding type 2 diabetes and becoming unhealthy from excess sugar and getting the wrong kind. You want sugar that comes from foods such as fruits and vegetables, yogurt, and milk.

These whole foods contain nutrients that are healthy for you including magnesium, fiber, potassium, and calcium. Natural sugars should come from these natural foods but even these sugars you shouldn’t go overboard with.

So what’s the limit on sugar each day? It’s 6 teaspoons for women and 9 teaspoons for men according to the American Heart Association. Again, a little sugar is fine, but know your limits and get them from the right sources! And remember when you’re shopping to read the labels! There weren’t nutrition labels years ago, but there are now so take advantage of it. Reading the ingredients is that important!

Final Thoughts

What is the Best Sugar Substitute For Diabetics Sugar substitutes for diabetes are not all the same. By now you might be deciding against them altogether, but know that there are a few good ones you can rely on. But in either case, it’s your health and diabetes to look out for.

If You Really Want to Reverse Your Type 2 Diabetes 

Then Click the Button Below!

If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to leave them below and pass this on to others who may need help. I would appreciate it! Thank you for reading and have a happy and a healthy one!


Bestseller No. 1
Care Touch Diabetes Testing Kit – Care Touch Blood Glucose Meter, 100 Blood Test Strips, 1 Lancing Device, 30 gauge Lancets - 100 count and Carrying Case
20,930 Reviews
Care Touch Diabetes Testing Kit – Care Touch Blood Glucose Meter, 100 Blood Test Strips, 1 Lancing Device, 30 gauge Lancets - 100 count and Carrying Case
  • FAST RESULTS – Get results in as little as 5 seconds.
  • NO CODING – Our monitors recognize batch codes encrypted on each test strip, so there is no need for you to manually insert any code with each new batch.
  • HYGIENIC STRIP EJECTION – Our state-of-the-art monitoring system includes a single touch strip ejection, so you no longer have to worry about manually removing the soiled strip.
  • MEMORY – Keep a survey of your health using the memory storage capable of saving up to 300 readings, while also keeping a continuous 14-day average.
  • Care Touch Diabetes Testing Kit – Care Touch Blood Glucose Meter, 100 Blood Test Strips, 1 Lancing Device, 30 gauge Lancets-100 count and Carrying Case
SaleBestseller No. 2
Blood Sugar Support Supplement - 20 Herbs & Multivitamin for Blood Sugar Control with Alpha Lipoic Acid & Cinnamon - 120 Pills - Arazo Nutrition
7,632 Reviews
Blood Sugar Support Supplement - 20 Herbs & Multivitamin for Blood Sugar Control with Alpha Lipoic Acid & Cinnamon - 120 Pills - Arazo Nutrition
  • Scientifically formulated; great care was put into combining just the right amount of 20 different ingredients into a premium formula designed to support healthy blood sugar levels
  • High potency; the unique combination in this blend is crafted to help support healthy glucose absorption and glucose production by your body; contains Gymnema, Alpha Lipoic Acid, Yarrow, Licorice, Cayenne, Banaba, Guggul, Bitter Melon, Juniper Berry, White Mulberry, L-Taurine & more
  • One capsule twice a day, five benefits; (1) supports normal blood sugar levels; (2) supports weight control and energy; (3) supports healthy sugar and carb absorption; (4) supports insulin levels; (5) supports heart health
  • Reliable; made in a GMP certified facility in America and third party safety tested for purity
  • Great value for money; 120 vegetarian capsules for a 60 days supply
SaleBestseller No. 3
Metene TD-4116 Blood Glucose Monitor Kit, 100 Glucometer Strips, 100 Lancets, 1 Blood Sugar Monitor, 1 Lancing Device, Blood Sugar Test Kit, No Coding
  • Accurate: Metene TD-4116 blood glucose meter and strips are produced with industry-leading chips and biosensor, equipped with industry-leading technologies, conducive to get accurate and reliable measurements
  • No Coding: The blood sugar meter gets into measure status automatically once insert the blood sugar test strip correctly to the bottom of the slot, easy to use and easy to read with large display for the senior
  • 7 Seconds And 0.7µl Blood: This blood glucose monitor takes just 7s and 0.7µl blood to get the glucose value; The lancing device has 5 depth options to minimize wound and reduce pain
  • Better Data Management: This glucometer stores the newest 450 blood glucose values and display the continuous 14/21/28/60/90 day average; the measurements could be exported with windows-based software; help you track and manage your blood glucose better
  • Diabetes Testing Kit 207 Piece Set: 100 glucometer strips, 100 30G lancets, 1 blood sugar meter, 1 lancing device, 1 control solution, 2 batteries, 1 protective wallet and 1 user manual; Please feel free to contact us if any problem when using this Diabetes testing kit
Bestseller No. 4
Ed Gamble: Blood Sugar
64 Reviews
Ed Gamble: Blood Sugar
  • Amazon Prime Video (Video on Demand)
  • English (Playback Language)
  • English (Subtitle)
SaleBestseller No. 5
AUVON DS-W Blood Sugar Kit (No Coding Required), High-Tech Diabetes Blood Glucose Meter with 50 Test Strips, 50 30G Lancets, Lancing Device
5,785 Reviews
AUVON DS-W Blood Sugar Kit (No Coding Required), High-Tech Diabetes Blood Glucose Meter with 50 Test Strips, 50 30G Lancets, Lancing Device
  • INSTRUCTIONAL VIDEOS. Insufficient blood applied to test strip will result in wrong readings. Please hold the lancing device firmly against your fingertip for enough sample. Watch our instructional videos in our listings to optimize your testing results. Our friendly customer support will always be here to answer your questions and help to resolve your concerns. (30 Day Money Back Guarantee)
  • EXCEEDS INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS. AUVON BGMs can function within ±10%, or ±10 mg/dl of laboratory values over 95% of the time, which is far beyond ISO 15197:2013 passing standard (within ±15% or ±15 mg/dl). The manufacturer is certified with CE mark, GMP, ISO 13485:2016, and ISO 15197:2013 without having any recall on the market in the past 14 years.
  • CUTTING-EDGE TEST STRIPS. We use cutting-edge test strips enzymes for blood glucose measurements. Our test strips are produced with unique Automatic Carbon Printing Technique to ensure that the quality of each batch of strips could be relevantly much more stable, precise and accurate. Additionally, PROMISED 0.16USD/pcs would keep you no pressure to repurchase.
  • KEEP TRACK OF DATA. Store your test results with time and date helps you track and manage your health while also keeping a continuous 7/14/30 average results. Automatic off means our device works longer without having to worry about wasting battery life.
  • ALL IN ONE: 1 x AUVON DS-W Blood Glucose Monitor, 1 x battery, 50 x Blood Test Strips, 50 x 30 gauge Lancets, 1 x Lancing device, 1 x Meter User Guide, 1 x Test Strip User Guide, Our Exclusive Lifetime Warranty and Technical Support and Friendly Customer Service.

Last update on 2021-09-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Home » Dieting » What is the Best Sugar Substitute For Diabetics?

Rob Sciubba

Rob Sciubba - Founder of NaturalWaystoLowerBloodSugar.com

Rob is an blogger who has type 2 diabetes and wants to spread the word treating diabetes. For the past 3 years he has provided valuable information about diabetes and lowering blood sugars and continues to offer additional ways to treat diabetes.

If you’re serious about treating your diabetes and lowering your blood sugars the natural ways, then you will learn from his website.

6 thoughts on “What is the Best Sugar Substitute For Diabetics?”

  1. Thanks Rob for great summary, I should get rid of Splenda ASAP! I tried Stevia and don’t like the taste of it, however it might depend on the brand. Do you know by chance any without aftertaste? Also I’ve heard about sugar replacement extract from monk fruit, however have not seen it locally yet. Is it really good? Thanks!

    • Hey Nixie,

      All sugar substitutes will have different tastes. I didn’t find Stevia to have an after taste and since it’s about the best, I’ll stick with it. But you can try others than may be more suitable for your tastes.

      I am not familiar with monk fruit but I’ve mentioned plenty of other options that are good.

      Give a few of them a try to see which you like best.

      Thanks for your input!


  2. Hi Rob,

    Excellent article, I really enjoyed the reading!

    Thank God, I don’t suffer from diabetes, but I do need to lose weight:) I was really surprised to read that Agave is one of the worst sugar substitutes, I use it almost in all my deserts. I will definitely get rid of it even right now!
    I also use maple and coconut sugar. So I’ll stick with them! What about Fructose? Does it raise the blood sugar?

    Thank you for this useful post!

    • Hi Daniella,

      It’s good that you don’t have diabetes but losing weight is always a good thing no matter what 🙂

      I personally don’t use sugar substitutes but Stevia would be the one if I did.

      The ones I listed are all good but with anything, never overdo it!

      As far as fructose goes? It does not increase blood glucose and diabetics can tolerate it better than other sugars!

      Thank you!

  3. Very informative post, I use stevia and raw honey if I am trying to sweeten something , I am not diabetic but have known for years that excess sugar is bad for you . I naturally shy away from sugar alcohols and always have but my mother in law is diabetic and she uses Splenda in her coffee and tea everyday , I keep trying to get her to stop so maybe I’ll show her this post and see if she listens to someone else lol

    • Hi Christina 🙂

      Thank you so much. Stevia and raw honey are good choices to replace sugar. It’s wise to stay away from the ones that aren’t good.

      It’s good that you’re not a diabetic. Yes excess sugar is just so bad for you. It’s good to know what foods to eat and what not to eat.

      I hope she does see this and stop using Splenda too.

      Thank you so much for your comments!



Leave a Comment